I agree that there hasn't been much to cheer about so far in this draft. The only really positive thing is the fact that the first 3 players drafted were white- when was the last time that happened?
As usual, most teams did a horrendous, irrational job of drafting, even without considering the built-in restrictions of the Caste System. Minnesota, Detroit and Carolina were especially bad. I guess Brad Childress just is not going to bring in any real competition for Tavarious Jackson, not matter how ridiculous he looks on the field. How could they have passed up Brohm and Henne in the second round? They even traded up, and had everyone thinking they were going to take a QB. But Matt Millen was not be outdone, as usual; apparently the Lions are planning on going into the season with tiny, perpetually injured Tatum Bell and his clone Brian Calhoun at running back. Poor Jon Kitna; he won't get any more protection from the fat sumo they reached for in the first round. Then Carolina drafts a running back in the first round, when they just spent a first rounder on DeAngelo Williams a few years ago. Williams has looked great in his inexplicably limited playing time. Meanwhile, teams that desperately need an upgrade at RB, like the Lions, Bears and Cardinals, ignore the fact that the second highest rated RB on most boards (Mendenhall) slid much farther down the first round than anyone expected. As always, NFL teams did little to make things easier for fantasy football owners...
What was most obvious was the Caste loyalty teams like the Vikings, Titans, Raiders and Redskins have towards their young black QBs. The Redskins, for instance, could easily have drafted a Brohm or Henne with one of their THREE 2nd round picks, during their strange slide. If any of the teams in question-especially the Vikings and Redskins- had young white starting QBs, you can bet they would have fought over Brohm or Henne like cats and dogs, and the talking heads would have nodded wisely and said "great value pick" or "you have to take a player that's rated that highly on your board at this point" or some other such words of wisdom. Instead, Brohm goes to the Packers, where young Aaron Rodgers finally has a chance to play. As Steve Young pointed out in some unusually insightful commentary, Rodgers already has enough pressure on him replacing Brett Favre; why add to that by bringing in such legitimate competition for him? Henne went to Miami, where young John Beck is already hanging by a thread as the likely starter (because as a white QB, he's already had the handful of games necessary for the coaches, drunk white fans and media jock-sniffers to determine if he's a "bust" or not). Beck can't be happy about having Henne as competition for his job. I also heard all the talking heads state that the Bears need to upgrade at QB (Steve Young went back to his normal self, lambasting Rex Grossman), while no one said the Vikings did. Also, it was agreed that Matt Leinert is not a guaranteed starter for Arizona. Can you imagine a black QB drafted that high, who wouldn't be guaranteed the starting job? But then again, if he was black, his backup would be Brooks Bollinger, Gus Frerotte or some equally inept veteran who represented absolutely no threat to start. No one noted that it would be great to bring some competition in for Jason Campbell, as it apparently is for Aaron Rodgers. Everyone seems to have forgotten that it was journeyman Todd Collins who led the Redskins on their season ending win streak.
I'm happy that Jordy Nelson went that high, but a black WR of his talent would probably have been gobbled up by a team like Buffalo or Tennessee, where he would have been an instant starter. At Green Bay, even if he isn't immediately designated for the "slot," he will probably never have a chance to be a real number #1 WR (Jennings is young and very productive).
Finally, it will be hilarious to watch all the "gurus" give out their draft grades to each team. Invariably, they will claim most teams drafted wonderfully, issuing only a few "Ds" and no "Fs." In reality, of course, many teams deserve an "F" and only a handful of teams do a really good job of drafting. The fact that they take almost all their alloted time to make EVERY pick, despite months of research into which players they want at which point, just reveals how pathetic they are at their jobs.