*Update: I will continue to update this list, cynicaloptimist, as Pro Day results come in.
A look at what this draft would look like for our guys without the caste system. Unfortunately every year phenomenal talents like Nile Knapp disappear after H.S to Div. III, the NAIA- or give up football all together due to lack of scholarships (so this isn't literally w/o a caste system). The dearth of white RBs in the FBS is saddening. The unfortunate treatment of our guys applies to most every position at times. As JC said- guys like Jameson Konz got jerked around in their careers at multiple positions, so caste coaching lowers their ranking unfortunately (due to lack of productivity). They should have picked offense or defense for Konz from the get-go ie. TE, WR, H-back, RB, LB or Safety.
*Note: Anyone listed as a PFA (priority free agent) or above, has the athletic tools- AND has shown at least some signs on the field they could make it in the NFL. Usually 7th round draft picks and PFAs are "sleepers" that could turn out to be nice players, but aren't worth an early pick. If a team gives these guys proper coaching and actually gives them good opportunity- they can succeed. I will list the players ranking if they are in the top 10 at either QB, RB or WR!
The 5 year draft average for RBs is 19 drafted. The FA trend number for RBs is 35. Here is my best attempt at a fair assessment of the limited number of white RBs given a chance to be successful in NCAA football.
RB:
1. Toby Gerhart (1st round) #1 RB; The best rushing prospect in this draft. Spiller and Best aren't far behind as rushing threats and Spiller is an absolute phenom receiving and returning kicks- Still Gerhart has shown some recent encouraging signs of potential as a receiver.
2. Jake Sharp (3rd/4th round) #9 RB *Nice Pro Day; combine snub
3. Trevyn Smith (5th round) *Combine snub
4. Blake Smolen (6th round) *WR prospect also; combine snub
5. Luke Lippincott (7th round) *Knee injury history/turf toe
6. David McCarty (7th round)
7. David Sinisi (PFA)
8. Kevin Harris (Possible tryout player) Has shown glimpses of legit NFL potential, but struggled through injuries and caste coaching- therefore he had low productivity
9. Jared Hawkins (Possible tryout player) " " Read above
10. J.T Rogen (Possible tryout player)
11. Trevor Theriot (Possible tryout player) Caste coaching and injuries ruined his career
12. Chad Kackert (Possible tryout player)
The year of the white WR! The 5 year average for WRs drafted is 33. The FA trend for WRs is 78. There are SO MANY good white WRs this year, that some are bound to get screwed.
WR:
1. Eric Decker (1st round) #3 WR *I'd rank him higher if healthy
2. Jordan Shipley (1st/2nd round) #5 WR
3. Blair White (2nd round) #7 WR
4. Riley Cooper (2nd round) #8 WR
5. Chris McGaha (3rd round)
6. Marc Mariani (3rd/4th round)
7. Kerry Meier (4th round)
8. Tim Toone (4th round)
9. Kevin Jurovich (4th/5th round)
10. Ryan Wolfe (5th round)
11. Bryan Anderson (6th round)
12. Andrew Brewer (6th/7th round)
13. Pat Simonds (7th round)
14. Max Komar (7th round/PFA)
15. Brett Hamlin (7th round/PFA)
16. Austin Rogers (PFA) *Knee injury history
17. Johnny Spevak (PFA)
18. Bobby Sewall (PFA)
19. Zeke Markshausen (FA)
20. Shawn Leonard (FA)
21. Harry Von Kann (FA)
22. Trey Stross (Possible tryout player)
23. Ryan Christian (Possible tryout player) *RB prospect also
24. Brad Kanuch (Possible tryout player)
25. Rocky Ross (Possible tryout player)
12 white athletes who could be used at multiple positions:
*In order of best position to worst in my opine
1. Tim Tebow (QB/Wildcat/RB/TE/WR) 1st round; #3 QB
2. Dennis Pitta (TE/WR/H-Back) 2nd round; #3 TE
3. Dan Lefevour (QB/Wildcat/RB) 2nd/3rd round; #6 QB
4. Jameson Konz (TE/WR/H-Back/RB) 4th round, #9 TE
5. Kerry Meier (WR/Wildcat/H-Back/TE/QB) 4th round
6. Blake Smolen (RB/WR) 6th round
7. Andrew Brewer (WR/Wildcat/QB)
8. Cody Slate (TE/H-Back/WR) 7th round; knee injury history
9. David McCarty (RB/WR) 7th round/PFA
10. Willie Rose (H-Back/RB/FB) 7th round/PFA
11. Matt Grothe (Wildcat/RB/WR/QB/S) PFA; knee injury history
12. Trevor Theriot (RB/H-Back/FB) Possible Tryout player; knee injury history and a victim of caste coaching after a stellar H.S career as a tailback
JC, Colonel Reb and others- let me know your thoughts and if I've missed any offensive skill players of note. I'm always more tuned into offensive skill players when I watch football, so those are the only guys I rank. I also focus much more on WRs than TEs.
BTW, I see Jameson Konz as a Vernon Davis type TE due to his body type, but of course he could very well be tried at WR or RB too if fair! I'd love to see someone else do some QB, TE, FB or defensive rankings if they had time to take the initiative. Cheers guys!
Edited by: ToughJ.Riggins