I do not at all question that Dirk is a phenomenal player, one of the best of this generation. He's a first ballot HOF'er, and that's all anyone needs to know.
Having said that, I agree with Deadlift that Dirk lacks that certain "It" factor when it comes to that final bit of mental toughness and what makes an alpha male truly stand out. Old school guys like Bird, Chambers, Majerle, and Stockton certainly had it. Today, it's players like Nash, Gasol, Ginobili, Bogut, etc. Dirk is just a level below them in that department, not skill-wise by any stretch, but that mental edge-wise, which is really something you're born with. I've known this for years, and it's not a knock against Dirk. Black or white, very few players have this killer intinct. I can name plenty of HOF-caliber black players (Karl Malone, David Robinson, Patrick Ewing, Clyde Drexler, Charles Barkley, etc, etc) who simply did not have it. Jordan had it, Hakeem had it, Kobe has it. It's a very rare commodity, if you will, and that's the way it ought to be.Edited by: foobar75