Because not many running qbs were accurate. The pistol formation should get credit. It allows for u to have the benefits of both shotgun passing and power running. Combine that w the zone read plus shanahans great run blocking scheme and defenses are confused. It's only his first year, teams will figure out how to stop him, they already can slow him down with short halftime adjustments, he didnt do much the second half 100 yards 1 td 1 int. he really doesn't take that many deep shots compared to the amount of dinking and dunking. When he does throw deep he isn't threading the needle or anything. It's a combo of great scheme and terrible defenses. Offensive schemes have gotten better tremendously over the years while defensive schemes have fallen behind and the talent has gotten worse plus rules that favor offense. I mean look at the Texans, they just got Whiter on defense and improved showing that teams need to stop ignoring White talent. Texans also have a great run blocking scheme, kubiak learned under Shanahan. Schaub is a good but not elite but puts up numbers. They were able to win a playoff game w a rookie backup rating of 97
Cam newton dresses like Carlton from fresh prince and has tried to act White. They wouldn't have had him drafted that high just to let him fall on his face. The plan looks more like to put any black qb out there that shows an ounce of talent, sometimes guys that just have the measurables and hoping some of them stick. I mean it's not improbable that one or two wind up being decent. I mean look at the past decade when they said the position would be revolutionized, tons of them got chances and only McNabb was successful long term. Dwfs have forgotten about the guys like akili smith, Aaron brooks etc. Brooks is an example of short term success. Had mike McCarthy as the oc, really didn't want brooks and upset that he had to adapt his play book. Brooks usually abandoned the play book and was basically playing backyard football w Joe Horn and took a while for teams to figure out while the Saints got rid of guys like Dellhome and Marc bulger.
Wilson should be the easier qb to figure out how to stop. The black quarterback for the 49ers will be the next to hype up. Good running game and they use the pistol formation. They play the Saints next and they have a tendency to make crappy qbs look like hall of famers
The fact is all qbs will eventually have to adapt to traditional pocket passing. The avg career for a rb is 3.5 yrs, franchise qbs need to last longer than that, so running isn't always going to be there to fall back on