I updated the previous list and now put together rankings for each offensive skill position. I tend to watch mostly offense and mostly guys who get the ball, so I didn't rank o-line or defense. I didn't rank FB because true FBs aren't used much anymore. I ranked H-Backs in their place. These are guys that can catch balls as TEs or swinging out from the backfield. H-Backs can also run and pass block and run the ball a bit when the situation calls for it. I have ranked each player that I feel should be drafted without the caste system and then continued with a short list of the top PFAs.
A few things to note:
1. A player will drop down if he isn't all that productive even if he is a workout warrior.
2. Productive players with pedestrian measurables (ie. Freddie Barnes, David Sinisi) will drop down in rankings. Freddie Barnes may be the best example of this in years. Barnes performed this season on level of Mike Hass when Hass won the Biletnikoff award. However Barnes does not jump as well and isn't as agile, quick or fast as Hass. ie. Hass's best tested measurables for the '06 draft: 4.58 40, 4.15 SS, 6.52 3-Cone, 9'8" BJ 36.5 VJ; Barnes: 4.67 40 (reported by NFLdraftscout as his best hand-timed 40 out of a range), 4.55 SS, 7.16 3-cone, 8'11" BJ, 30.5 VJ.
3. Injured players like Eric Decker and Demaryius Thomas tend to drop in rankings no matter how talented they are. For instance, Eric Decker would probably have been ranked my #1 or #2 WR if healthy, but I have him ranked 4th right now. Players with questionable work ethic or character issues will drop down in the rankings as well. This is even if they have serious talent. Among the aforementioned are Dez Bryant, Brandon Lafell, Mike Williams and Jevon Snead.
4. Productive players in the FBS stand out for higher rankings more than productive players in the lower levels.
5. This list is not literally without the caste system, because there are unfortunately lots of talented whites who fall victim to caste coaching and never got the chance to produce. And freakish talents like Nile Knapp disappear to Division III, NAIA or stop playing football all together every year- after H.S- due to lack of scholarships.
Here's the list:
QB:
1. Sam Bradford
2. Tim Tebow
3. Jimmy Clausen
4. Colt McCoy
5. Tony Pike
6. Dan Lefevour
7. Jonathan Crompton
8. Zac Robinson
9. John Skelton
10. Jarrett Brown
11. Mike Kafka
12. Darryl Clark
13. Joe Webb
14. Jevan Snead
Top PFAs:
15. Levi Brown
16. Sean Canfield
17. Tim Hiller
18. Max Hall
19. Matt Nichols
20. Thaddeus Lewis
RB:
1. Toby Gerhart
2. Jahvid Best
3. C.J Spiller (I dropped him down after watching extensive highlights of him because he's too much like Reggie Bush. He might be a little bit better of a rusher than Bush up the middle, but like Bush isn't an "elite" rusher. He's a phenom receiver out of the backfield and a crazy good returner though.
4. Ryan Mathews
5. Ben Tate
6. Montario Hardesty
7. Jonathan Dwyer
8. Joe McKnight
9. Jake Sharp
10. Anthony Dixon
11. James Starks
12. Lonyae Miller
13. Andre Dixon
14. Deji Karim
15. Trevyn Smith
16. Chris Brown
17. Joique Bell
18. Blake Smolen
19. Luke Lippincott
20. Stafon Johnson
Top PFAs:
21. LeGarrette Blount
22. Curtis Steele
23. Charles Scott
24. Pat Paschall
25. David McCarty
H-Backs:
1. Dorin Dickerson
2. Jameson Konz
3. Clay Harbor
4. John Connor
5. Rashawn Jackson
6. Richard Dickson
7. William Rose
Top PFAs:
8. Cody Slate
9. Manase Tonga
10. Jack Corcoran
WR:
1. Golden Tate
2. Dez Bryant
3. Eric Decker
4. Damian Williams
5. Demaryius Thomas
6. Jordan Shipley
7. Blair White
8. Dexter McCluster
9. Arrellious Benn
10. Riley Cooper
11. Mardy Gilyard
12. Carlton Mitchell
13. Chris McGaha
14. Brandon Lafell
15. Taylor Price
16. Jacoby Ford
17. Marc Mariani
18. Andre Roberts
19. Kerry Meier
20. Tim Toone
21. Dezmon Briscoe
22. Kevin Jurovich
23. Emmanuel Sanders
24. Mike Williams
25. Bryan Anderson
26. Jeremy Williams
27. Armanti Edwards
28. Ryan Wolfe
29. Antonio Brown
30. Scott Long
31. Andrew Brewer
32. Marcus Easley
33. Shay Hodge
34. Pat Simmonds
35. Kyle Williams
36. Danario Alexander
Top PFAs:
37. Freddie Barnes
38. David Reed
39. Stephan Williams
40. David Gettis
41. Max Komar
42. Tim Brown
43. Donald Jones
44. Duke Calhoun
45. Chris Carter
TE:
1. Rob Gronkowski
2. Jermaine Gresham
3. Jimmy Graham
4. Aaron Hernandez
5. Dennis Pitta
6. Anthony Mccoy
7. Ed Dickson
8. Garrett Graham
9. Tony Moeaki
10. Andrew Quarless
11. Michael Hoomanawanui
12. Jeff Cumberland
13. Scott Sicko
14. Fendi Onobun
Top PFAs:
15. Nate Byham
16. Colin Peek
17. Mickey Shuler
18. Michael Palmer
19. Nathan Overbay
20. Steve Maneri
Lastly, I figure I may take heat for ranking Eric Decker 3rd. The reason for that is that Decker's injury to a ligament in his foot is rather significant. If not for this injury Decker would probably be my #1 WR. Decker is a slightly richer version of Michael Crabtree without the headcase baggage. I spent a lot of time watching football last season and watching Youtube and Yahoo video highlights to make this list, so if you don't like it make your own list lol! Cheers guys.
Edited by: ToughJ.Riggins