WA33, Michael Vick IMO performed as the 3rd best QB in the NFL last year behind Rodgers and Brady and it will be interesting to see if he keeps that level of performance up. I agree with you on McNabb and Freeman being talented, but IMHO Vince Young was a very solid starting QB. You could even make the argument he was slightly above average. He had a great record of 32-17 as a starter, so he is a winner. And his pocket sense and accuracy in his last season as a starter with Tennessee improved. He also adds another dimension with his running ability and ability to extend the play. If Cam Newton ends up like Vince Young, but an emotionally stable version, he'd be a pretty good (although not great) starting QB.
If he's such a "winner" in the rabidly pro-black NFL, how come not a single team was interested in having him become their starter this season?
Young's main accomplishment as far as I'm concerned was to vividly illustrate the league's racial dynamics. You had a Tennessee team that packed it in when Kerry Collins was the starter in 2009, going 0-6, then being almost unbeatable when Young became the starter. It wasn't that Young was an upgrade; it's that the team wasn't going to try unless Collins was benched and Young started. They were a mediocre team that played hard for a black QB but not a White one.
Young is a very poor thrower, and like all black QBs, his feet can only carry him so far when they're young. When black QBs have been in the league a few years they have to become decent pocket passers or fall by the wayside. Vick is just now learning to play in the pocket, but he was freakishly fast enough that he could get away with it until he was 30; Young and the others can't.