What is the most famous catch in baseball history? Willie Mays' over the shoulder catch against Vic Wertz in the 1954 World Series. Jim Edmonds just made an over the shoulder catch just short of the wall and neither Joe Buck nor Tim McCarver raised their voices above their usual broadcasting monotone. That is the height of bias. McCarver remarked with irritation how Edmonds had "trademarked" that catch, as if each and every one hasn't earned him his due. Buck said that Edmonds had won six Gold Gloves. But the spectacular catch itself wasn't worth any verbal excitement.