Philadelphia Eagles General Thread

Steele has a shot at being the fourth RB on Philly but not much of one. Unfortunately, Will Shipley is one of the backs ahead of him, so if Steele does stick it will be primarily as a team mascot type of WSTD.

A lot of rave reviews of Steele's last game, like this one, but check out the last two sentences. "Smart, tough and productive," "precisely the kind of player you want on the practice squad." And here I thought those types of players are "precisely" the ones you want on the 53. He'll never overcome those two early fumbles with the Chiefs barring Hillis Curse luck somehow working in his favor:

THE CRAZY HURDLING MADMAN CARSON STEELE: How do you not love this kid? To put Carson Steele’s 6-catch, 88-yard receiving performance Saturday night into some perspective, the most yards he ever had in a college game was 57 in Ball State’s 20-16 loss to Eastern Michigan in Muncie, Ind., in 2022. The most he’s had in an NFL regular-season game is nine, in the Chiefs’ 2024 win over the Panthers in Charlotte, N.C. Steele’s 88 yards were the most by an Eagles running back in a preseason game since Raheem Mostert had 93 against the Jets (along with 69 rushing yards) in a loss to the Jets in East Rutherford in 2015. Steele, who finished at UCLA after two years at Ball State, really shined Saturday night. He showed soft hands, a great feel for running in space and tremendous toughness in traffic as well as plus athleticism hurdling defenders twice, including on his touchdown. You never want to get carried away with strong preseason perrformances against backups, but there’s a lot to like about Steele’s game. Steele spent his first couple years with the Chiefs and played in all 17 games in 2024, rushing 56 times for 183 yards with seven catches for 26 yards. There isn’t a roster spot for him here, but assuming the Eagles can get him through waivers he’s precisely the kind of player you want on the practice squad. Smart, tough and productive.
 
Some added AI assisted research into Steele's chances:

Carson Steele (RB, Eagles) — Roster Outlook

Status: Genuinely split, 50/50 among credible sources.

  • The performance: 18 touches, 117 total yards, 1 TD vs. Patriots — including two highlight-reel hurdles, one landing in the end zone.
  • Bearish (The Athletic's Kubena & Berman, Bleeding Green Nation): Predict he misses the 53. Reasoning: room is crowded (Barkley/Bigsby/Shipley locked in), and he hasn't practiced as an H-back/fullback in camp — meaning the "hybrid" role that could save him isn't actually being developed. As a 2024 UDFA, he'd be exposed to waivers if cut, so the Eagles risk losing him outright rather than stashing him on the practice squad.
  • Bullish (SI/Onsi, Yardbarker): Both flip to a 4-RB roster after this game, slotting Steele in as a true RB/FB hybrid — tied to reports the offense wants a fullback piece.
  • The swing factor: not his talent (nobody disputes that) — it's whether the coaching staff actually uses him at fullback/H-back before cuts. That's the entire disagreement.
Bottom line: One more preseason game (Aug 28 vs. Bengals) will likely decide it. Right now it's a genuine coin flip among beat writers, not a consensus either way.
 
Back
Top