ToughJ.Riggins
Hall of Famer
You make some good points Riddlewire, but it still made the scout look foolish to the general public which hurt his standing. He should have "posed it as a question" as Tom Iron has suggested as a good method before. The way I posed the question would be perfect.
I would beg to differ that McFadden isn't shifty. He's pretty darn shifty, just not as shifty as Woodhead. McFadden is another Reggie Bush IMO. He doesn't know how to grind out the yards up the gut. McFadden also has much more pure straight-lined speed than burst, although his burst is above average. His shiftiness and burst aren't good enough for the next level to make up for his lack of leg drive and upright running despite his blazing speed.
Basically, McFadden will need a good o-line so he can get into the open field where his speed and agility will work to his advantage. His burst isn't that impressive.
McFadden's 10 yard time or 1.50 is above averge, but by no means spectacular. Actually Jacob Hester ran the the exact same 10 yard time, but is written off b/c he ran a 4.6 flat 40 yard.
To compare measurables: IMO a guy who runs a 1.45 10 yard and a 4.5-4.55 40 yard, is more valuable than a guy who runs a 1.55 10 yard and a 4.4 flat 40 yard. IMO a superior 3-Cone, short shuttle and 10 yard dash time together, are more important to a RB than a blazing 40 time. Unless the fast guy w/ average times in the other drills is running a 4.4 and the slow guy with elite times in those areas is running a 4.7. There are always exceptions!
Edited by: ToughJ.Riggins
I would beg to differ that McFadden isn't shifty. He's pretty darn shifty, just not as shifty as Woodhead. McFadden is another Reggie Bush IMO. He doesn't know how to grind out the yards up the gut. McFadden also has much more pure straight-lined speed than burst, although his burst is above average. His shiftiness and burst aren't good enough for the next level to make up for his lack of leg drive and upright running despite his blazing speed.
Basically, McFadden will need a good o-line so he can get into the open field where his speed and agility will work to his advantage. His burst isn't that impressive.
McFadden's 10 yard time or 1.50 is above averge, but by no means spectacular. Actually Jacob Hester ran the the exact same 10 yard time, but is written off b/c he ran a 4.6 flat 40 yard.
To compare measurables: IMO a guy who runs a 1.45 10 yard and a 4.5-4.55 40 yard, is more valuable than a guy who runs a 1.55 10 yard and a 4.4 flat 40 yard. IMO a superior 3-Cone, short shuttle and 10 yard dash time together, are more important to a RB than a blazing 40 time. Unless the fast guy w/ average times in the other drills is running a 4.4 and the slow guy with elite times in those areas is running a 4.7. There are always exceptions!