2026 Indianapolis Colts

Freethinker

Hall of Famer
Joined
Oct 3, 2008
Messages
9,676
Location
Suffolk County, NY
The Colts were a CF favorite last year and were having a great season at 8-2 before Daniel Jones was hurt. After the injury, the Colts went 0-7 the rest of the way, finishing 8-9 — becoming the first team in NFL history to finish with a losing record after starting 8-2. Ouch. The Colts, if they keep their White athletes healthy, should again be one of the best squads to follow. Let's jump in.

Total White Athletes on Roster (Starters in bold)
17 Whites total, with 6 starters. Grade: D-
[With Current Injuries: 16 Whites total, 5 starters]

QB - Daniel Jones, Riley Leonard
WR - Alec Pierce (IR)
TE - Tyler Warren, Will Mallory
LT - Bernhard Raimann, Charlie Heck
LG - Dalton Tucker
C - Tanor Bortolini
RG - Matt Goncalves
RT - Luke Tenuta

DE - Caden Curry
WLB - Bryce Boettcher
SS - Hunter Wohler
NB - Gushiken Kapena (Not counting him but could be considered a Caste Buster as a Native Hawaiian / Japanese playing CB)

K - Spencer Schrader
P - Rigoberto Sanchez (Castizo?)
LS - Luke Rhodes

IR - Carson Towt (TE)
PS - Reid Holskey (OT), Nolan Rucci (OT), West Weeks (LB), Daniel Scott (S), Jacob Bobenmoyer (LS)

Well if and when the get their short term IR players back, they pretty much hold form from last year. Decrease in offensive lineman but an increase in defensive players. I'll take it!

Daniel Jones delivered a stunning 2025 renaissance with the Colts, leading to the aforementioned excellent start with career-high efficiency (68% completion, 8.1 yards/attempt) before a broken fibula and then a torn Achilles in back-to-back weeks ended his season, sending Indianapolis' season down the crapper. Much of that early magic ran through Alec Pierce, who broke out alongside him with the first 1,000-yard season of his career (47 catches, 1,003 yards, 6 TDs) and led the NFL in yards per reception for a second straight year — production that made him Jones' favorite downfield target and earned him a four-year, $114 million extension in March 2026.

Both re-signed with big expectations for 2026, but the season has opened rockier than anyone hoped. Jones, fully healthy, has started 1-2 with just 611 yards, 3 TDs, 3 INTs, and an 80.8 passer rating. Pierce, meanwhile, needed offseason heel surgery that cost him camp, then re-aggravated the same injury in Week 2 and landed on IR after managing only 5 catches for 72 yards. With Pierce sidelined, Jones has lost his most explosive weapon — and the two players' fortunes now look tightly linked: Indianapolis' offense, and Jones' own statistical bounce-back, likely hinge on how fully Pierce can return to the form that made last year's hot start possible.

That leads to young, potential star tight end Tyler Warren as the candidate needed to step up and fill the reception void. So far he'd done so, with 18 catches for 2 TDs but with modest yardage. So he's not replacing the vertical threat lost by Pierce, at least not yet. Warren had an impressive 817 yards as a rookie and would have a good shot at his first thousand yard season if he can break off some longer catches in the coming weeks with the target volume he will receive.

The offensive line is no longer a snowplow, with Braden Smith departing via free agency. 4 out of 5 White is still great, but the diminishing depth is a cause for concern for future seasons. Indianapolis enters 2026 with a line built around two anchors. Quenton Nelson remains the unquestioned centerpiece at left guard — a seven-time Pro Bowler and future Hall of Famer who's been one of the league's most dominant interior blockers for nearly a decade. Bernhard Raimann protects the blind side off a four-year, $100 million extension, backed up by legitimately elite 2024 tape and a very above average 2025 season. I'd put him on the short list of top NFL tackles. Bortolini and Goncalves have performed admirably at their positions by all accounts. Offensive line should be a strength of the team once more.

Defense actually has some overachievers playing this season. Bryce Boettcher, drafted 135th overall out of Oregon (Second-Team All-Big Ten, Burlsworth Trophy winner as the nation's top former walk-on), has quickly carved out a real role for the Colts, leaning on the smooth coverage ability and sharp pre-snap communication that made him a standout linebacker in college. Through 3 games in 2026, he's totaled 13-14 tackles (4 solo, 9-10 assisted), highlighted by a 7-tackle effort in Week 1 against Baltimore. He's yet to start a game (28-34% of defensive snaps), but his reliable tackling and coverage instincts give him a genuine path to expanded playing time on a Colts defense that's struggled significantly as a unit, ranking near the bottom of the league in total yards allowed.

After his Lisfranc foot injury wiped out his entire 2025 rookie season, Hunter Wohler is back and active for the Colts. He's gotten to play early in the season, recording a 7-tackle effort in Indianapolis' Week 2 game against Kansas City. Given the athletic tools and versatility that made him a standout at Wisconsin (86.9 overall PFF defensive grade, 9.55 Relative Athletic Score), his return gives the Colts depth and a player to develop going forward. 53% and 31% of defensive snaps in the last 2 weeks is a positive sign.

The final defender is Caden Curry, a Greenwood, Indiana native who grew up attending games at Lucas Oil Stadium, had a breakout senior season at Ohio State in 2025 — leading the Buckeyes in both sacks (11) and tackles for loss (16.5), including an 11-tackle, 5-TFL, 3-sack performance against Washington that earned him Big Ten Defensive Player of the Week honors. He finished his college career with 111 tackles, 15.5 sacks, and First-team All-Big Ten recognition, notably outproducing teammate Arvell Reese (a top-5 overall pick) at the position. Unlike Reese, Curry had to wait until the Colts selected him with their 6th-round pick (214th overall) in the 2026 draft. Gee whiz, isn't it funny how it always seems to work out that way? However, don't expect the goy-brained DWFs to start noticing the pattern. Anyways, the team has praised his versatility to line up both inside and on the edge. Hopefully he ends up being a huge steal for him and has a better career than Reese.

I'll be rooting for the Colts to tread water until Pierce returns and then hit high gear again. I'm also hoping the leaky defense will improve as the Colts winning the AFC South would be the best outcome for CF followers.

Update: after trade deadline
 
Last edited:
Colts have traded their top 2 wide receivers while Alec Pierce remains on IR with no set return date. They are setting up Daniel Jones to absolutely look awful with the putrid WRs left on the roster. The immortal bust Laquan Treadwell is likely the #1 receiver going forward. Barf. The only positive is that Warren might get a heavy volume of targets. That should at least be the plan if they had any sense....
 
The whole sudden takedown and destruction of this team has seemed strange to me, even by NFL standards. I admittedly haven't watched them much this season but Daniel Jones was really good last year before his unfortunate Achilles tear, which takes a long time to fully recover from. They had Jones in his prime, the best deep threat in the league in Alec Pierce who was finally going to be used as their number one receiver, a top RB in Taylor, an up and coming young TE in Tyler Warren, and one of the best o-lines in the league.

The defense wasn't terrible and has a couple promising talents in Boettcher and Wohler (who had a remarkable 16 tackles in his injury-caused start on Sunday).

And now they're suddenly starting over? The injuries have been unfortunate, but the number of injured players this year, not just the White ones we follow but black ones too, has reached an absurd level as anyone who plays fantasy football, especially IDP fantasy, can testify.
 
The whole sudden takedown and destruction of this team has seemed strange to me, even by NFL standards. I admittedly haven't watched them much this season but Daniel Jones was really good last year before his unfortunate Achilles tear, which takes a long time to fully recover from. They had Jones in his prime, the best deep threat in the league in Alec Pierce who was finally going to be used as their number one receiver, a top RB in Taylor, an up and coming young TE in Tyler Warren, and one of the best o-lines in the league.

The defense wasn't terrible and has a couple promising talents in Boettcher and Wohler (who had a remarkable 16 tackles in his injury-caused start on Sunday).

And now they're suddenly starting over? The injuries have been unfortunate, but the number of injured players this year, not just the White ones we follow but black ones too, has reached an absurd level as anyone who plays fantasy football, especially IDP fantasy, can testify.

Good to see you back Don.

DE Caden Curry has also been very good. I won't speculate but it seems that the girl boss owner is intent on breaking the team down that the now departed GM Ballard built. Jones wasn't given much to work with due to injuries this year including recovery from his own as you mentioned. Ballard wasted 2 1st round picks on an overrated Sauce Gardner who gave up a huge play near the end of the game to put the Cowboys in great field position after the Colts went up by three. Ballard also wasted the 2023 1st round pick on mega bust Richardson.

Part of me thinks they are going to tank for Arch Manning, that's my theory anyways. The Manning connection being obvious and while Arch is closer to Eli than Peyton he has been better than the media wants anyone to believe and worth a 1st round pick. That is without the obvious marketing angle and the chance to get the biggest name QB prospect since Andrew Luck (not saying Arch is Andrew Luck but the name goes a long way) and the franchise has been in need of a franchise QB since Luck's abrupt retirement in 2018. At least we will see a young White group of defensive players for the rest of the year.
 

Jones put out of his misery by the Colts. Job goes back to one of the all time busts. Colts could have gotten draft capital for Jones a few weeks ago in a trade but instead cut him.
 

Jones put out of his misery by the Colts. Job goes back to one of the all time busts. Colts could have gotten draft capital for Jones a few weeks ago in a trade but instead cut him.
I’m ok with this. I’d assume Jones will sign on with some sort of playoff contender looking for veteran depth. The Colts roster right now is a disaster, and one I’d rather a White QB not be associated with, seeing the inevitable failure that the rest of the season will be.
 
I agree. I think they are tanking for Manning.
Only problem is they traded their 1st to the Jets for Sauce Gardner. LOL. This is an all-time awful trade as they’d likely get a day 3 pick for “Sauce” at this point.

Assuming Manning were to come out this year, vs transferring somewhere like Ole Miss, then I’d imagine he could be had in the mid to late 1st? Would the Colts be able to trade back in?
 
Only problem is they traded their 1st to the Jets for Sauce Gardner. LOL. This is an all-time awful trade as they’d likely get a day 3 pick for “Sauce” at this point.

Assuming Manning were to come out this year, vs transferring somewhere like Ole Miss, then I’d imagine he could be had in the mid to late 1st? Would the Colts be able to trade back in?

Forgot about that all time idiotic trade.

Hopefully Richardson struggles to the point Riley Leonard gets a shot. They should have kept Ehlinger.
 
The Colts definitely looked like a team last night that was told to (continue to) tank. Jonathan Taylor all of a sudden couldn't gain more than a yard or break a single tackle, while Jones was also awful, and Tyler Warren ignored except for one catch. And who knows if the now forgotten Alec Pierce is now healthy enough to play but is being left in moth balls.

The franchise's girl boss, looking so impressive prowling the sideline with her notebook, is well on the way to keeping the Colts a bottom feeding franchise for years to come. They were much better off with a high and drunk Jim Irsay letting the GM and coaching staff run the team.
 
Laquon Treadwell, Quez Watkins, Ashton Dulin, Anthony Gould are the Colts receiving corps. Can't be a much bigger statement to blow up the caste system instead of let black scrubs be employed.

Colts traded away Pittman last for a 6th round pick last March, Allen for a 6th round pick, Josh Downs for a 4th and 5th round pick and Quenton Nelson for a third round pick and 2028 fifth round pick. Not exactly ammo to trade up into the first.

The Gardner trade is just more comical the more I think about it.
 
The Colts definitely looked like a team last night that was told to (continue to) tank. Jonathan Taylor all of a sudden couldn't gain more than a yard or break a single tackle, while Jones was also awful, and Tyler Warren ignored except for one catch. And who knows if the now forgotten Alec Pierce is healthy enough to play is now healthy enough to play but is being left in moth balls.

The franchise's girl boss, looking so impressive prowling the sideline with her notebook, is well on the way to keeping the Colts a bottom feeding franchise for years to come. They were much better off with a high and drunk Jim Irsay letting the GM and coaching staff run the team.
Yes I was going to say they found their pops stash of prescription pills. Supposedly the three sisters were going be a female equivalent of the Three Wise Men but so far it's been disaster.

Kirk Cousins had trade value at 38 years old with only value for win now teams but Jones in theory could be a qb for the future but instead he will be released similar to a shot veteran and now they will start the totally inept Richardson, move over Arizona, Indy is the new most inept organization in football...
 
Back
Top