Freeman being the best isn't saying much, most of his play is the typical dink and dunk. His top receiver last night was Doug Martin, the runningback, and before the 4th quarter when the defense started playing even worse as far as corners, his 2nd leading receiver was Dallas Clark, the tight end. I mean look at the pass last week that was almost 95+ yard td if it weren't for the safety chasing him down and tackling, pretty much all of those yards were after the catch. Just like RG3 and Cam Newton, we never see that "rocket arm" they are supposed to possess. Well we see Cam go more vertical than those 2 which is why he has more interceptions. Freeman has more vertical throws than RG3 but I think with his struggling either he, or the coaching staff figured out how to reduce the turnovers, so I think he is a better version of David Garrard, in the sense that he actually has the ability to go vertical, he just doesn't do it that often. I think out of the 3 young black qbs, he is the one that sticks the longest. RG3 showed in college going vertical but with receivers having at least 5 yards of seperation, tighter windows in the NFL, not the best wr corps but Brees makes it work with who? the slowest starters in the league in Colston who is more like a hybrid wr/te and doesn't run the supposed 4.5 that he came out with in college. Lance Moore who should have been shown the door in favor of Hass in a fair world. Then there is Devery Henderson who has hands of stone and stopped being a deep threat about 3 or 4 years ago, now with a new up and comer with even worse hands and injury prone, but not as injury prone as Adrian Arrington (who spent like 4 years on the roster because of "upside" [based on one good game against a Florida secondary that started true freshmans] but couldn't even make it through practice healthy, and we are supposed to believe Chase Lyman given the boot so quickly because of a few injury problems). Yes Brees is elite but if thats what class they are going to put RG3 in then that is who I will compare him to.
And the really the main difference between Freeman and RG3 is that RG3 can run faster and the coach has designed qb runs for him. Defenses will eventually find a way to shut RG3 down but they do have a nice system, they use the pistol formation the most which is what I have been wondering why the NFL doesn't run more often, it combines the advantages of being in shotgun with the advantages of being in singleback or i formation, the runningback is downhill when he takes the handoff, you can run all the same plays you would out under center, in shotgun the problem is running, the main thing you have is the draw, the Patriots were creative in 2010 with Woodhead getting a few direct snaps and running a normal running play, there was also the toss, which was counted as a pass because it went like 2 millimeters forward but other than that not much you can do. Then you get the benefits of being in shotgun, and being that most qbs played in shotgun in college its not that big of a jump, the only thing you have to work with is timing with the snaps and the handoffs because of the unusual line up, qb 4 yards back and tailback 7 yards back. RG3 lines up often with 3 other guys in the backfield, power running, and usually just has one of those guys sneak out into the flat on playaction. They aren't maximizing the potential of that kind of offense, frankly because RG3 probably can't do it, with all of that running, when you do play action you usually want to throw it deep, hes done that twice this season. So he will be figured out and stopped, but I would like to see the pistol stay.