G
Guest
Guest
Who do you guys think would win a game between the best white players in the NFL and the best black players.
G
Guest
Guest
blacks.
Colonel_Reb
Hall of Famer
Landslide and rob3873, you have been found out. What you got is banned!
G
Guest
Guest
Colonel_Reb said:
Excuse me? Banned for what?
G
Guest
Guest
Cmon Reb there is no way with the amount of black athletes could whites field a comparable team. We only have 3 and a half cornerbacks anyways if you count Eric Weddle.
Tom Iron
Mentor
Colonel_Reb,
Sir, do you think the answer to people like this is to ban them? Couldn't you easily take care of them in open dialogue?
Tom Iron...
Sir, do you think the answer to people like this is to ban them? Couldn't you easily take care of them in open dialogue?
Tom Iron...
G
Guest
Guest
Tom Iron said:
Thats what I'm talking about. Although I don't know what I said that constitutes getting banned, if that is your first impulse to anything you don't agree with, than maybe you shouldn't be posting on forums online. Everyone online is not your personal yes man.
Colonel_Reb
Hall of Famer
Tom, with all due respect, we have been bombarded by trolls lately and I'm losing patience. I don't mind defeating them in arguments, as I've been doing so fairly often for over 3 and a half years. A lot of people won't listen to a word you say, no matter how wrong they are. I'm tired of dealing with them. If you want to spend/waste your time doing so to everyone that drops in on us, go ahead. Feel free to do what you want, but I'm not obligated or enthusiastic about doing so all the time. I have more important things to spend my time on.
G
Guest
Guest
Anyways who would be in your 22 in an all white lineup?
Colonel_Reb
Hall of Famer
We've had these discussions before. If you really want to know, look it up using the search function.
G
Guest
Guest
Lineups change with time. The 2008 season is getting ready to start and I thought it was an appropriate time. You don't have to be part of the discussion Colonel_Reb, but I'm sure plenty others would be.
Colonel_Reb
Hall of Famer
In other words, you don't want to take the time to go looking for it. I can tell all you want to do is start arguments and demean whoever anyone lists. Trolls like you are a dime a dozen.
G
Guest
Guest
Troll am I? I thought you had more important things to spend your time on. Apparently you don't. I just came for a discussion.
Landslide said:
Yes, this has been discussed many times. The real issue is that whites are slotted racially beginning at an early age, and many white high school stars arerarely recruited by the major programs at many positions, if at all. So any comparison ofa white NFL team vs. a black one is going to be skewed by that reality. Blacks are about 90 percent of starting defenders, 95 percent of WRs and 100 percent of tailbacks. Why wouldn't they defeat an all-white team?
Why don't you at least list your teams then tell us who you think would win and why. Edited by: Don Wassall
Tom Iron said:
Tom, we have done so over and over and over again. Most of these types have never read the posting guidelines or studied what Caste Football stands for. They'll read a post or two then register and want to start arguing. We all have limited amounts of time and it gets quite boring and repetitive, which is why this is a troll-free site.
G
Guest
Guest
From reading old posts it seems that the minute anyone disagrees on here they are banned. I had one simple question and was threatened with being banned. So my question is if I begin to talk about who I would think would win, would I immediately get banned? Because you seem to be a little quick with the trigger.
so you're saying that this team would not have a shot at winning?
Brady, Manning
Hester, Leonard, Kreider
Curtis, Walter, Gonzalez, Welker, Nelson
Heap, Daniels, Scheffler
plenty of great white o-linemen to choose from
Kerney, Allen, Kampman, Vanden Bosch
Gregg, Hovan, Bingham,
Wilhelm, Posluszny, Ruud, Urlacher, Vrabel
Weddle, Doughty, Gregory, Russell, Condren at CB, Giordano
and that's from the top of my head.
Brady, Manning
Hester, Leonard, Kreider
Curtis, Walter, Gonzalez, Welker, Nelson
Heap, Daniels, Scheffler
plenty of great white o-linemen to choose from
Kerney, Allen, Kampman, Vanden Bosch
Gregg, Hovan, Bingham,
Wilhelm, Posluszny, Ruud, Urlacher, Vrabel
Weddle, Doughty, Gregory, Russell, Condren at CB, Giordano
and that's from the top of my head.
You're not banned, who are your teams and who would win?
Read the posting guidelines and see if this is a site you support. The reality is that if we allowed trolls and opponents to post, we would be swarmed with them,and if it seemsthat some of us are quick to be suspicious it's from experience. Every other sports board out there is dominated by the viewpoint that blacks are superior athletes and that there is no discrimination or stereotyping when it comes to white athletes. I really don't know what your position on this is from your initial post.
BTW, Rob3873 or whatever his name is, is banned. He's been banned several times before and will be banned immediately any time he tries to re-register.
Read the posting guidelines and see if this is a site you support. The reality is that if we allowed trolls and opponents to post, we would be swarmed with them,and if it seemsthat some of us are quick to be suspicious it's from experience. Every other sports board out there is dominated by the viewpoint that blacks are superior athletes and that there is no discrimination or stereotyping when it comes to white athletes. I really don't know what your position on this is from your initial post.
BTW, Rob3873 or whatever his name is, is banned. He's been banned several times before and will be banned immediately any time he tries to re-register.
backrow said:
The problem I have with these comparisons is that it's just one team. Because of the Caste System, many all-black teams could be fielded but only one or two white ones. To me it doesn't mean anything, we all know whites make great football players and there should be far more of them in the NFL.
G
Guest
Guest
I'll give you guys my lineups later tonight. I gotta go get something to eat first.
White Shogun
Hall of Famer
- Joined
- Mar 2, 2005
- Messages
- 6,285
Landslide said:
Are you an Internet noob or something? It seems to me if you are going to ask a question like this you must have put some thought into this and already have at least some of the positions filled on your mythical football team. Why didn't you just post them when you asked the question in the first place?
GWTJ
Mentor
Landslide said:
The people here who truly agree with the purpose and message of this site make much better first time posts than this. There are usually some words of thanks and appreciation that this site exists and then maybe a question or some input.
I agree with the Colonel on this one. I don't think this guy is on the level. I do hope that Landslide proves the Colonel and I wrong.Edited by: GWTJ
lumsdenpower
Mentor
maybe black would win because of the reason Don said. But that don't matter. The real thing who matter is that, when that's all white high school vs all black high school. The white team, are a lot more often the victorious team.
Landslide said:
Still eating?