right now ashley cole is considered one of the best fullbacks in the world, but i remember that when chelsea had bad results last season everybody was saying that he was getting old and that he should be replaced
now his team got better so it's all forgotten, but remember that when you are a fullback it's really easy to appear good when your team wins it all
for example see abidal at barcelona, he was the best left-back according to experts, because barcelona was winning everything
but when he played with france it was obvious that it was not the case
when his club was a little bit worse, it became more obvious that abidal had been over-rated:
http://rutube.ru/video/369027b364e93676b7e2260a787c4ba9/
http://rutube.ru/video/8d99fe4f8ebc9031b6b638e3b658bd46/
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OYyOvYIlv_w&feature=youtu.be
and here are his last matches for the french national team: (i won't translate the text in french but you can understand it pretty well with a translator like google traduction)
-worst mark of the match against bielorussia:
"Abidal (4) : il faisait son grand retour en Bleu après son opération d’une tumeur au foie. Mais la belle histoire a tourné au film d’horreur pour l’arrière gauche, qui a été contraint à marquer contre son camp. Un match à vite oublier."
-worst mark of the match vs albania:
"- Abidal (4,5) : soirée compliquée pour Abidal. Replacé dans l’axe en l’absence du duo Mexès-Rami, le joueur du Barça ne s’est pas vraiment montré à son avantage. Dans le dur tout au long des 90 minutes, l’ancien Lyonnais a éprouvé les pires difficultés à trouver ses marques."
with this goal:
http://youtu.be/PgvoTipNHVw
-then he got the worst mark of the match against mexico in the 2010 world cup (2/10!) the worst match of the french national team because of the huge consequences it had (we are no longer a top european team and we are in spain's group for the qualifying to the 2014 world cup):
"Abidal (2) : décidément, la défense centrale française a failli ce soir. Si William Gallas n’a pas brillé, Éric Abidal a encore un peu plus sombré. Responsable du premier but encaissé par la France, suite à un mauvais placement, le gaucher a été à côté de la plaque. Pour couronner le tout, le numéro 3 a provoqué le pénalty mexicain transformé dans la foulée par Blanco. Un hors sujet en bonne et due forme."
the same could be said about patrice evra, who is considered one of the best fullbacks in the world when his team wins, but in france he is badly considered because he has been awful everytime he played for france
i heard former international players such as eric di meco (who used to be a left back like evra) or jean michel larqué say that he was not a good left back - and it means a lot because it's really unusual to say it clearly like that, you never hear anyone saying "he is a bad player"
the latest is van der wiel, he's rated very highly yet with holland he was horrible at the 2012 euro champs
here is jean michel larqué's reaction when he heard his price (6 millions):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uNLkJ4CFQxM&feature=share&list=PL0949B32FC37BC0BD
i'm not saying that ashley cole is a bad player, but he's probably way over-rated and currently i suspect that he's finished