GWTJ-
I respect your viewpoint. I am in complete argreement with you, btw, on
refusing to go to Viet Nam. It's the one good thing Ali ever did, imho,
whatever his motives.
You are right to mention wrestler Georgeous George. Ali was definitely
influenced by him. However, the difference is that George never had any
real impact on society. Ali's impact on our society, fueled by a
fawning press, was huge. I have to disagree with you about no boxer
imitating Ali. Sugar Ray Leonard aped Ali's style, if not all his
antics. "Macho" Camacho, Mike Tyson and many, many others certainly
copied the classless boasting and pro-wrestling like threats from Ali.
I also have to disagree with you about black athletes in the past not
being jerks. True, the behavior wasn't as egregious 20 or 30 years ago,
but there were plenty of arrogant blacks in sports in the '60s, '70s
and '80s. Where do we begin? How about Jim Brown? A great RB, but a
walking time-bomb who has been charged over the years with repeated
violent offenses against women, the last less than a decade ago, when
he was already in his sixties. He also has "hate whitey" written all
over him, as he plays the part of elder black statesman on various
sports broadcasts, with his ever- present African dashiki atop his
head. Richie "Dick" Allen was a long-time Major Leaguer whose surly,
drugged-out attitude would fit right in with today's athletes. Kareem
Abdul-Jabbar used to get into fights with only white players during his
early years in the NBA. Like so many blacks on the court then (and
now), he just didn't stand for any whitey stopping him on defense. Dave
Winfield, before he became a long-time Major Leaguer, was a starter on
the University of Minnesota's basketball team. He participated, along
with the other 4 black starters, in a vicious assault on Ohio State
center Luke Witte. Winfield and co. beat Witte to a bloody pulp on the
court, apparently riled up by the fact that the white center had
dominated them. Witte was never the same player afterwards, but
Winfield never suffered for his part in this crime, and it was never
mentioned during his years in baseball. Duane Thomas, RB for the
Cowboys and Redskins, was another surly black, doped-up athlete who
clearly hated whites. We all remember Kermit Washington's savage attack
on Rudy Tomjanovich, which effectively ended Rudy's days as a top
scorer and was clearly racially motivated. There are many other
examples I could cite. Of course, with today's sports being saturated
with criminal scum like Iverson, Sprewell, Moss, Dillon, etc., things
have certainly become a lot worse. But the "black power" gang a few
decades back weren't exactly slackers.
Cassius Clay "won" the heavyweight championship in a highly dubious
way. In the first fight against the seemingly unbeatable Sonny Liston,
the champ mysteriously didn't answer the bell for (I think, not sure)
the seventh round, even though he had not been hit that hard in the
fight. To my knowledge, this was the first we'd ever heard of the term
"not answering the bell." I could be wrong, but before this I don't
know of any instance where a fighter just didn't get off his stool for
the beginning of the next round. In the rematch, Ali "won" in an even
more counterfeit way. He "knocked out" Liston with what even
establishment reporters termed "the invisible punch." Liston's death
several years later under questionable circumstances fueled some
conspiracy theories, and may well have been due to his starting to talk
about those fights with Clay being fixed. After he became Muhammed Ali,
the fights became ever more theatrical. By any legitimate standard, Ali
won a whole lot of decisons he should have lost. All the Norton fights.
Ernie Shavers. Then there were the really ridiculous "knockouts"
against Oscar Bonavena and the ultimate absurdity of the "rope-a-dope"
vs. George Foreman. I think that, even if he was the nicest guy on the
planet, and hadn't helped to ruin our culture, Ali could still be
severely criticized for the way he managed to make an already
shady game seem even more corrupt.
Anyhow, food for thought.