Sherdog's MMA P4P Top 10 - October '10

[DixieDestroyer]

Here's Sherdog's latest top 10 P4P fighters.

http://www.sherdog.com/news/rankings/Sherdogcoms-Pound-for-Pound-Top-10-27769y

***Here's my version...

1) GSP
2) Aldo
3) Fedor
4) Silva
5) Edgard
6) Fitch
7) Machido
8) Shields
9) Maynard
10) Bader

 

[Howard]

TO DIXIE: Your top 5 is excellent and then you go downhill quick. Bader has no business in the top ten and you know it. Maynard does not belong either. Fitch and Shields are okay I guess. I am biased against Fitch because he is boring as hell and does not try to finish fights. Shields should fight at 185. His "victory" over Kampmann was unimpressive.He has a hard time making 170.

 

[DixieDestroyer]

TO DIXIE: Your top 5 is excellent and then you go downhill quick. Bader has no business in the top ten and you know it. Maynard does not belong either. Fitch and Shields are okay I guess. I am biased against Fitch because he is boring as hell and does not try to finish fights. Shields should fight at 185. His "victory" over Kampmann was unimpressive.He has a hard time making 170.

Bader might be a little stretch...right now. When Bader takes care of afrolete Jon "YOnes" Jones, I think he'll be right in line for a title shot.

Shields may go up to 185 if he can't best the winner of Kos vs. GSP (part 2).

 

[Doc Holliday]

pretty good, can't complain bout' your list.

Even though he's injured I'd have to put Mauricio Rua above Machida.

As much as we might not like it, Cain Velaszquez has to be in top 10 for now. he is 9-0 & just ko'd Brock Lesnar pretty easily.

Cain got rocked pretty easily & often against Kongo & I don't think he's going to be a long reigning champ(Ala Fedor). Some people roun' here are saying he's gonna be a one-n-done champ, meaning Junior Dos Santos might KO him.

I think JDS & well as Carwin(When healthy), & even Big Country Nelson all match up favorably with him. But for now I think he belongs on the top 10 list. YUK!!!!!