Well, there's been talk of Calzaghe fighting Hopkins in early 2008. That could still happen after a Calzaghe/ Kessler fight in September (provided Calzaghe wins, of course.) It's not either/ or.
Beating those two guys would do a lot for Calzaghe's legacy. Taylor would be great, too, but Pavlik would be the logical next fight for him. I'm sure we would all love to see that! I know I would. Tarver would be decent, but Jones hasn't won a meaningful fight in almost four years, so I don't know what beating him would prove. There's also criticism that Calzaghe has been a champ for all these years but still hasn't unified the division. Beating Kessler would give him three belts (he probably wouldn't bother with Berrio, or whoever beats him, but it would unify the division.)
As for Kessler, Calzaghe would probably retire soon after their fight, and that would leave Kessler to potentially dominate his division for years to come, even if has one lousy loss on his record. Or, if he beats Calzaghe, well, his stock will go through the friggin' roof! He'll be a proven champion with three belts. Not too shabby. And he would be more likely to fight Berrio or equivalent) and unify the division. Hmm, white undisputed champion... sounds good!
Basically, Calzaghe is running out of time, and he needs to go after any top fighter who will fight him. Kessler, Taylor, Hopkins/ Wright, Tarver, Chad Dawson, or Glenn Johnson would all be fine with me. But no more Calzaghe/ Manfredo's! His next fight needs to be a big fight. If that's Kessler, so be it.
Edited by: JD074