South Africa’s rugby squad versus American football

Bucky

Hall of Famer
Joined
Jul 20, 2018
Messages
9,156
Too bad our ((government)) won't offer asylum to White S. Africans.. They'd be a natural fit in states like Kansas, Nebraska, Iowa with their farming expertise. A lot of those states are facing declining older populations(with Mexicans moving in, in droves). They'd be great at American Football with some guidance as well!
 

SneakyQuick

Mentor
Joined
Sep 11, 2021
Messages
1,477
I’d say you have a better shot at being elected president than our government does of giving white South Africans asylum.
Also I’m sure they aren’t eager to leave, after all they created the country and have been there for a long time. If they wanted to come here I’m sure they could individually but how would they sell ? Who is going to invest in. South Africa farmland
 

Bob

Newbie
Joined
Aug 25, 2015
Messages
29
While the South African rugby team has a far fairer ratio of black and white players compared to the NFL, over the past two decades it has shifted significantly from an essentially all-white team when they returned to international competition in the mid-90s (post-Apartheid).

At the 1995 Rugby World Cup there was only one black player in the squad, Chester Williams (whose position was wing, the equivalent of a WR/CB in football). This was probably an artificially low number of non-white players, as ethnic groups such as the Cape Coloureds always had strong rugby participation.

Basically ever since 1995 though, the Springbok team and its racial make-up has become extremely political. Rugby is huge part of white Afrikaner culture in South Africa, and particularly in the Apartheid days the Springboks were seen by opponents as being a symbol of the regime.

While there were a couple of failed attempts from politicians in South Africa to remove the Springbok emblem and replace it with something else, for the past 20 years there has been a fairly consistent push towards "transformation" in the national team - with the goal of bringing representation in the squad in line with South Africa's demographics.

This has resulted in a quota system which specifies there must be a baseline percentage of black/non-white players in both the starting line-up and extended squad. Although some of these players are certainly deserving, there have been and continue to be instances where white players are forced out of the starting team or the squad to make room for a non-white player who is simply not as good.

Despite this meddling, the Springboks have performed remarkably well, and even won the most recent Rugby World Cup in Japan. However they can be a wildly inconsistent team, as illustrated by their record against their biggest rival - New Zealand. While before the 1990s South Africa had a slight edge in head to head victories (dating back to the 1920s), over the past three decades New Zealand have won about 70 per cent of their fixtures against South Africa.

I don't know of any South African rugby players who have had a go at playing American football, but there are certainly a few examples of the children of immigrants to the USA having success. Former Steelers guard David DeCastro is of South African descent - his father played rugby at the University of Cape Town. Linebacker Nate Landman, who went undrafted in this year's draft, is the son of Shaun Landman, who played rugby for Zimbabwe in the 1990s.
 

SneakyQuick

Mentor
Joined
Sep 11, 2021
Messages
1,477
That’s terrific information and not entirely surprising. I was just thinking that given the less than 8% demographics of white South Africans the fact the team is as light skinned as it is was somewhat remarkable.

I guess the point I was aiming at in this thread is that an African country that is on the road to Zimbabwe and is less than 10% European lineage, still has a National team percentage wise well that is whiter than would an analogous NFL all star team.

if that idea is upsetting to anyone who considers it but they still follow the nfl, then I don’t know what to say.


Could anyone here realistically imagine a 50% white NFL or even a 45% one ? For a variety of reasons I don’t think I will see that in my lifetime. Doesn’t upset me too much because I don’t watch it much (ex maybe half the super bowl), but for true football fans here I just don’t understand how y’all can support a league that is so biased.
 

Phil

Guru
Joined
Mar 25, 2011
Messages
153
https://www.ultimaterugby.com/south-africa/squad

Just take a glance at the photos and consider that if the the us were to field a single national team for American football what it would look like .


Also keep in mind South Africa is less than 10 percent purely white European descent.


Interesting to consider at least.
Any Afrikaner who has even a smidge of self respect wouldn't be part of this team. They are playing for a government that absolutely hates them with a passion. A government whose political idols have sang songs about killing Afrikaners.
 

SneakyQuick

Mentor
Joined
Sep 11, 2021
Messages
1,477
And yet somehow whites are still a bigger part of this team than whites would be in the us in American football.
 
Top