Your Opinions

whiteathlete33

Hall of Famer
Joined
Mar 18, 2007
Messages
12,669
Location
New Jersey
I have a question. What do u guys feel the real percetages of whites at CB, WR, RB, should be in the NFL if there was no caste system. I am interested in hearing you opinions.
 

Don Wassall

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Sep 30, 2004
Messages
30,401
Location
Pennsylvania
WR: at least 80 percent white


RB: about half white


CB: at least three fourths or more white


If Major League Baseball wasn't fanatically committed to bringing in as many non-American players as possible, the product would look a lot like college baseball, e.g. overwhelmingly white, 95 percent or more. Baseball is a sport that tests all the basic qualities of athleticism, not just speed -- hand-eye coordination, power, endurance, consistency, intelligence, unselfishness, feel for the game, etc. The very slight advantage on average that blacks have in straight-line speed is negated by the significantly larger number of white athletes from which to draw, many of whom will have the needed speed to play at the highest levels.


Football also tests all attributes of athleticism andnot just straight line speed. With no Caste System, college and professional football would be predominantly white. The exact percentage is of course a guess, but mine would be in the area of 75 to 80 percent white, about what the NFL and AFL were in the mid to late 1960s before the Caste System was instituted with a vengeance (and not coincidentally when the Cultural Marxist revolution to make the U.S. a non-white country also kicked into permanent high gear).


At 20 to 25 percent of players in a "level playing field" NFL, blacks would be foundat about twice their proportion of the U.S. population, acredit to their athleticism and interest in football. Edited by: Don Wassall
 

lumsdenpower

Mentor
Joined
Sep 4, 2005
Messages
958
Location
Quebec
Don you forget LB lol, at least 90 percent. Today the majority of LB miss a lot off tackle 'cause they go for the big hit with their helmet and don't wrapp..
 

Freedom

Mentor
Joined
Dec 15, 2005
Messages
812
Location
Tennessee
I would say roughly 60-70% white(by US census definition). 5-10% pacific islander and asian, and 25-35% black. Why so high? Because in a lot of areas where football is big, there is also a larger black population. Louisiana and Mississippi are roughly 35% black. Texas is only 12% black, but that is because many recent Mexican immigrants, who are usually unconcerned with football, are considered white. I bet when white hispanics are taken out of the equation, Texas has a much larger black population. Wikipedia says they historically made up one third of the population.

The only major white bastions of high school football are Ohio and Pennsylvania.

CB: 50%
WR: 70%
RB: 85%Edited by: Freedom
 

whiteathlete33

Hall of Famer
Joined
Mar 18, 2007
Messages
12,669
Location
New Jersey
i would say about 60 % running back, 60% cb, about 70 % wr. But not this nonsense of only a handful of white wide receiver, no white rb or true cb.
 

whiteCB

Master
Joined
Apr 14, 2005
Messages
2,282
Freedom said:
The only major white bastions of high school football are Ohio and Pennsylvania.

CB: 50%
WR: 70%
RB: 85%

Hell yeah!!! That's because Ohio and Pennsylvania kick ass! The two best pound for pound football states. Ohio has grown so many quality white football players the past few years.
 

white is right

Hall of Famer
Joined
Feb 16, 2006
Messages
10,035
Don Wassall said:
WR: at least 80 percent white


RB: about half white


CB: at least three fourths or more white


If Major League Baseball wasn't fanatically committed to bringing in as many non-American players as possible, the product would look a lot like college baseball, e.g. overwhelmingly white, 95 percent or more. Baseball is a sport that tests all the basic qualities of athleticism, not just speed -- hand-eye coordination, power, endurance, consistency, intelligence, unselfishness, feel for the game, etc. The very slight advantage on average that blacks have in straight-line speed is negated by the significantly larger number of white athletes from which to draw, many of whom will have the needed speed to play at the highest levels.


Football also tests all attributes of athleticism and not just straight line speed. With no Caste System, college and professional football would be predominantly white. The exact percentage is of course a guess, but mine would be in the area of 75 to 80 percent white, about what the NFL and AFL were in the mid to late 1960s before the Caste System was instituted with a vengeance (and not coincidentally when the Cultural Marxist revolution to make the U.S. a non-white country also kicked into permanent high gear).


At 20 to 25 percent of players in a "level playing field" NFL, blacks would be found at about twice their proportion of the U.S. population, a credit to their athleticism and interest in football.
If there wasn't whatever form of bias/self exclusion for whatever reason, the NFL numbers should reflect the percentages of the early 70's. I would slightly disagree with Don on the running back totals I would say it would be higher on the white side and the corner totals would be lower. maybe those numbers would be reversed. If cornerback would be more physical(ie pre 78 rules) the numbers for white corners would rise though...Edited by: white is right
 

jaxvid

Hall of Famer
Joined
Oct 15, 2004
Messages
7,247
Location
Michigan
I agree with Don's numbers but with a qualification. For running back I would only think that white players would be at that perdentage if the game was played like it was (and should be): that is-- more physical runners. Today's game doesn't even use the fullback (white or black) and rarely uses a power running game. Even in the good ol' days there were a lot of black runners.

Also white-is-right's observation about CB is spot on and also an issue of style of play.
 
Joined
Jan 5, 2005
Messages
476
Location
United States
To be completely honest, the numbers of blacks would be insignificant at the professional level because without the caste system, they couldn't cut it at the college level. For the overwhelming majority of Blacks to make it through High School and on to College based solely on their own merit is an unattainable reality. You would see college numbers upwards of 95% White and the Professional ranks would be even more so.
 

Don Wassall

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Sep 30, 2004
Messages
30,401
Location
Pennsylvania
reclaimsocal said:
To be completely honest, the numbers of blacks would be insignificant at the professional level because without the caste system, they couldn't cut it at the college level. For the overwhelming majority of Blacks to make it through High School and on to College based solely on their own merit is an unattainable reality. You would see college numbers upwards of 95% White and the Professional ranks would be even more so.


Good point, though I-A college football is essentially the NFL's minor league system. It's a financially lucrative arrangement for both principals, and especially a windfall for the I-A programs since they are grooming football players to be professionals without having to pay them anything while taking in many millions of dollars in revenue,while also pleasingthe reigning totalitarian gods of political correctness to boot.
 

white is right

Hall of Famer
Joined
Feb 16, 2006
Messages
10,035
Don Wassall said:
reclaimsocal said:
To be completely honest, the numbers of blacks would be insignificant at the professional level because without the caste system, they couldn't cut it at the college level. For the overwhelming majority of Blacks to make it through High School and on to College based solely on their own merit is an unattainable reality. You would see college numbers upwards of 95% White and the Professional ranks would be even more so.


Good point, though I-A college football is essentially the NFL's minor league system. It's a financially lucrative arrangement for both principals, and especially a windfall for the I-A programs since they are grooming football players to be professionals without having to pay them anything while taking in many millions of dollars in revenue, while also pleasing the reigning totalitarian gods of political correctness to boot.
You have a point there the amount of guys that make the NFL from the "beer" leagues are minimal. I can only recall Eric Swann and maybe Joe Horn making the NFL without college experience. In the old days "Night Train" made the NFL out of the beer leagues. At one time in Canada the Senior League provided quite a few talents but I haven't heard one non college player making a team in years......
smiley5.gif
 

jaxvid

Hall of Famer
Joined
Oct 15, 2004
Messages
7,247
Location
Michigan
I think Johnny Unitas came out of semi-pro ball too which would be the best example. In that era there were probably many others as colleges at that time were learning institutiions not indoctrination institutions.
 

devans

Mentor
Joined
Jul 7, 2005
Messages
729
Location
Outside North America
IMO
WR: about 66% white
RB: 40 - 50% white
CB: about 50% white

IMO CB should be very close to the figure to WR. I've gone for slightly higher for WR because of the hand eye coordination and "hands" required. I don't buy into this concept that cornerback is just so difficult to play, and requires such exceptional athleticism, that white people can't do it.

Good post by the way WhiteAthlete!
 

whiteathlete33

Hall of Famer
Joined
Mar 18, 2007
Messages
12,669
Location
New Jersey
OK. Let me explain it this way. We only have a handful of white receivers and safeties in the NFL. But why are they even there if the black athlete is so superior. How can these few guys compete in the NFL with the black athlete. If the black athlete was so superior as they want us to think this handful wouldn't even be in the NFL. It would be totally black. If this handful of guys can compete so can the rest. Its almost like a quota of how many white guys they can put in the NFL. Basically if even a handful can suceed in the Nfl then dozens and dozens more can. This proves the black athlete is not superior.
 
Joined
May 8, 2006
Messages
1,144
Location
New Jersey
Freedom said:
The only major white bastions of high school football are Ohio and Pennsylvania.

CB: 50%
WR: 70%
RB: 85%

Not necessarily. Nebraska, amongst some other midwestern states, are also hotbeds for White football.
 
Top