PFF's Top 101 Players of 2011

[Woody]

Pro Football Focus has an excellent top 101 players of 2011 list.
While there are many big omissions and puzzling additions, you probably won't find a better or more fair list out there.

http://www.profootballfocus.com/blog/category/features/top-101-of-2011/

You may have trouble navigating between the different segments of the list, but I got the hang of it pretty quickly.

Notable omissions IMO:
Mankins
Urlacher
Sean Lee
Jake Long
C. Barwin

 

[Woody]

Also Jason Witten.
Was very puzzled by Daryle Smith of JAX, but hey I guess they've determined he does something well enough.